Open-Loop Tracking Experiment

In this experiment, the motion of the camera is identical to the range experiment.

However, the system works keeping track of the last estimated transformation and using it as initialization to the next step. Thus, we expect a bigger working range.

Again, we present plots of the estimated centroid of the object and the matching error.

  Cartesian Log-Polar
Centroid cartcenter.jpg logcenter.jpg
Matching Error cartcorner.jpg logcorner.jpg

The following table summarizes some of these results. The break down is measured when error on the centroid or the matching error are bigger than 2 pixel.

Range Cartesian Break-Down (effective area scale) Log-Polar Break-Down (effective area scale)
1 step = 2.25 pixel n.a. n.a
2 step = 4.50 pixel 13.22% 6.06%
3 step = 6.75 pixel 25.92% 6.06%
4 step = 9.00 pixel 25.92% 10.78%
5 step = 11.25 pixel 33.85% 10.78%
6 step = 13.50 pixel 42.84% 24.24%
7 step = 15.75 pixel 42.84% 24.24%
8 step = 18.00 pixel 52.89% 24.24%
9 step = 20.25 pixel 52.89% 24.24%

 

We also present images obtained by the system in situations (40% size and 30% size) where the cartesian version of the algorithm starts breaking down:

Scale = 40% size

  Cartesian Log-Polar
Estimated trajectory
Last image
Registered image

Scale = 30%

  Cartesian Log-Polar
Estimated trajectory
Last image
Registered image